Anderson-Hsiao Instrumental Variables Estimator
Also known as: Anderson-Hsiao Estimator, AH IV Estimator, Dynamic Panel IV Estimator, Anderson-Hsiao Araçsal Değişken Tahmincisi
The Anderson-Hsiao IV estimator is a method for consistently estimating dynamic panel data models that include a lagged dependent variable as a regressor. Proposed by Theodore Anderson and Cheng Hsiao in 1981, it resolves the Nickell bias that arises when fixed effects are eliminated by first-differencing, by instrumenting the differenced lagged dependent variable with its own second lag in levels or differences.
Read the full method
Sign in with a free account to read this section.
Method map
The neighbourhood of related methods — select a node to explore.
When to use it
Use the Anderson-Hsiao estimator when you have a balanced or mildly unbalanced panel with a moderate number of time periods, a lagged dependent variable that introduces dynamic endogeneity, and individual fixed effects that must be removed. It is appropriate when the panel is long enough to allow at least three time periods per unit and when the idiosyncratic errors are not serially correlated. Relative to Arellano-Bond GMM, it uses fewer moment conditions and is simpler to implement, though less efficient. Prefer GMM-based alternatives when efficiency is paramount or when the instrument count can be managed without weak-instrument concerns.
Strengths & limitations
- Eliminates Nickell bias caused by including a lagged dependent variable alongside fixed effects
- Simple two-instrument setup reduces the risk of instrument proliferation common in full GMM
- Consistent under mild assumptions: strict exogeneity of regressors and no serial correlation in errors
- Foundational method that laid the groundwork for all subsequent dynamic panel estimators
- Less efficient than Arellano-Bond GMM, which exploits the full set of available moment conditions
- Requires at least three time periods (T >= 3) to construct valid instruments, limiting applicability to very short panels
- Instrument strength can be weak when the autoregressive parameter is close to unity, inflating IV variance
- Does not accommodate predetermined or endogenous covariates beyond the lagged dependent variable without additional instruments
Frequently asked
Why must we first-difference the model before applying the instrument?
First-differencing eliminates the unobserved individual fixed effect, which is correlated with all regressors including the lagged dependent variable. Without removing the fixed effect, OLS is inconsistent because the fixed effect induces correlation between the regressor and the composite error. Differencing solves this but creates a new endogeneity problem that IV then addresses.
When should I use y_{i,t-2} in levels versus Delta y_{i,t-2} in differences as an instrument?
Both are valid under no serial correlation, but the level instrument y_{i,t-2} is generally preferred when the series is stationary, as it tends to be more correlated with the endogenous differenced regressor. The differenced instrument Delta y_{i,t-2} may be preferred when levels are close to a unit root, though weak-instrument concerns arise in both cases near non-stationarity.
How does Anderson-Hsiao differ from Arellano-Bond GMM?
Anderson-Hsiao uses only one or two instruments (the second lag in levels or differences), whereas Arellano-Bond GMM stacks all available lags as instruments, exploiting additional moment conditions for efficiency gains. Anderson-Hsiao is consistent but inefficient relative to Arellano-Bond; it is simpler to implement and less prone to the instrument proliferation problem that can inflate GMM standard errors in small samples.
Sources
- Anderson, T. W., & Hsiao, C. (1981). Estimation of dynamic models with error components. Journal of the American Statistical Association, 76(375), 598–606. DOI: 10.1080/01621459.1981.10477691 ↗
How to cite this page
ScholarGate. (2026, June 2). Anderson-Hsiao Instrumental Variables Estimator. ScholarGate. https://scholargate.app/en/econometrics/anderson-hsiao
Which method?
Set this method beside its closest kin and read them side by side — the library lays the books on the table; the choice is yours.
- Instrumental Variables in Health ResearchHealth Economics↔ compare
- System GMMEconometrics↔ compare