So sánh phương pháp
Xem các phương pháp đã chọn cạnh nhau; những hàng khác biệt được làm nổi bật.
| Phân tích chương trình dựa trên tài liệu× | Phê bình văn bản học× | |
|---|---|---|
| Lĩnh vực | Phương pháp thực địa | Phương pháp thực địa |
| Họ | Process / pipeline | Process / pipeline |
| Năm ra đời≠ | 1950s–1980s (consolidated as a distinct approach) | Antiquity; modern systematic method c. 1850s (Lachmann) |
| Người khởi xướng≠ | Rooted in curriculum theory (Tyler, 1949) and document analysis methodology (Bowen, 2009) | Classical philologists (Karl Lachmann foremost in systematic method) |
| Loại≠ | Qualitative/interpretive document-based research | Humanistic / philological research method |
| Công trình gốc≠ | Bowen, G. A. (2009). Document analysis as a qualitative research method. Qualitative Research Journal, 9(2), 27–40. DOI ↗ | West, M. L. (1973). Textual Criticism and Editorial Technique Applicable to Greek and Latin Texts. Teubner. ISBN: 978-3519074014 |
| Tên gọi khác | curriculum document analysis, curricular document review, document analysis of curriculum, DCA | lower criticism, editorial criticism, philological criticism, manuscript criticism |
| Liên quan≠ | 4 | 5 |
| Tóm tắt≠ | Document-based curriculum analysis is a qualitative research method that systematically examines written curriculum artifacts — textbooks, syllabi, national standards, policy documents, scope-and-sequence guides, and lesson frameworks — to reveal intended learning goals, ideological assumptions, gaps, and alignment between policy and practice. It treats curriculum documents as primary data rather than supplementary material, applying structured content and interpretive analysis techniques to answer questions about what knowledge is valued, how it is sequenced, and whose perspectives are represented. | Textual criticism is a systematic philological method for identifying, comparing, and evaluating variant readings across multiple manuscript or print witnesses of a text in order to reconstruct the most accurate version of the original — or the author's intended — text. Applied since antiquity to classical, biblical, and literary works, it remains the foundational editorial method in classical studies, biblical scholarship, medieval studies, and critical editing of literary works. |
| ScholarGateBộ dữ liệu ↗ |
|
|