Editing and Montage
Editing is the joining of shots into sequences, the system that controls the relations of graphics, rhythm, space, and time across cuts and shapes how a film unfolds for the viewer.
Definition
The selection and combination of shots into a film, and the analysis of how cuts and transitions organize graphic, rhythmic, spatial, and temporal relations.
Scope
This topic covers the assembly of the film from individual shots. It examines the dimensions of editing, graphic, rhythmic, spatial, and temporal relations, and the dominant system of continuity editing, including the 180-degree rule, shot/reverse shot, eyeline match, and match on action, that renders cuts unobtrusive. It contrasts continuity with discontinuous and montage styles, and addresses the practical craft and aesthetics of cutting.
Core questions
- What relations between shots can editing control, and to what effect?
- How does the continuity system make editing invisible and space coherent?
- How do discontinuous and montage styles depart from continuity norms?
- How does the editor's craft shape rhythm, emotion, and meaning?
Key theories
- Continuity editing system
- The set of conventions, codified in Film Art, that maintains clear, continuous space and time across cuts through devices like the 180-degree rule, shot/reverse shot, and the match on action.
- The rule of six
- Murch's prioritized criteria for the cut, ranking emotion highest, followed by story, rhythm, eye-trace, two-dimensional continuity, and three-dimensional spatial continuity.
History
Editing developed from the simple splicing of early actualities into the continuity system perfected in 1910s American cinema, which subordinated cuts to clear storytelling. The Soviet montage theorists of the 1920s offered a rival, expressive conception of editing as collision. Later, the analytical decoupage of classical Hollywood, the jump cuts of the New Wave, and the rise of nonlinear digital editing each reshaped practice, while editors such as Walter Murch articulated the craft's underlying principles.
Debates
- Invisible cutting versus expressive montage
- Continuity editing aims to be unnoticed in service of the story, whereas montage traditions foreground the cut as a creative and rhetorical device, a tension running through editing history.
Key figures
- Walter Murch
- Ken Dancyger
- David Bordwell
- Dziga Vertov
Related topics
Seminal works
- bordwellthompsonsmith2020
- murch2001
- dancyger2018
Frequently asked questions
- What is continuity editing?
- It is the dominant editing style that joins shots so as to preserve a clear and continuous sense of space and time, using conventions such as the 180-degree rule, shot/reverse shot, and matching action across cuts.
- What is a jump cut?
- A jump cut is a cut between two shots of the same subject that are only slightly different in position or angle, producing a jarring jump in time or space, famously used in the French New Wave to break continuity norms.